Fi’zi:k M5 Donna mountain bike shoe review

Fi;zi:k’s offering for female mountain bikers, the M5 Donna.

Rachel Fenton, marathon MTB racer, put a pair of fi’zi:k M5 Donna shoes through their paces. Could they can keep up!

It’s a bold statement, but the fi’zi:k M5 Donna shoe is the most comfortable off-road cycling shoe I have come across. Combine that with a stylish design and clever mountain bike specific features such as anti-scratch toe coverings and in my opinion you have a winner.

Over the years, I’ve struggled to find a pair of mountain bike shoes that fit me. I’m either between sizes, or the shoes are too narrow causing my toes to go numb – never a good thing when you’re trying to concentrate on those challenging trails.

Welcome then, the Fi’zi:k M5 Donna shoe, which appears to have solved all my problems. After chatting with UK brand manager Hamish Bingley I chose a 38.5 (UK 5.5) – half a size larger than I normally wear. Logic being that these shoes are ‘Italian sized’ i.e. small, so you are advised to go bigger (unlike the Fi’zi:k road shoes which are apparently more ‘British’).

My immediate reaction on trying them on was that they were very comfortable – not something I usually associate with cycling shoes! They are well padded around the ankle and the supple mesh and microtex upper moulds to the foot. Compared to the other MTB shoes I have worn recently the sole is extremely flexible. For commuting to work – which for me includes a stroll through the Greenwich foot tunnel – this makes them absolutely spot on as there’s enough flex to allow a proper walking motion. It feels like you are wearing a pair of trainers.

Riding offroad it was a little strange at first to feel my pedal pressing through the sole when riding out of saddle and I was a little concerned that I was losing some power to flexing the sole rather than turning the pedals. It turns out though this is less of a worry once you attach a race number to your bars. The gains from having comfortable feet for the first time in years for me far outweighed anything else. That said, Fi’zi:k also produce a second level of shoe, the M1, in the men’s range with a stiffer full carbon sole for racing. It would be great for this option to be given to women too.

Fi’zi:k have clearly thought through the challenges shoes come across when in use. Mimicking climbing shoes, the toe is covered in anti-scratch leather, so you don’t have to worry about toes poking out after one too many scuffs with the trails!

One feature I am most impressed by is the anti-scratch leather toe. As a marathon racer I have unfortunately spent a good deal of time pushing my bike up a rocky hillside destroying the toes of untold numbers of shoes. As a commuter, stopping at traffic lights every 5 minutes, unclipping and clipping back in has a similar effect. Basically, I scuff the toes of my bike shoes a lot! The fi’zi:k M5 range all have toe covers akin to those on climbing shoes and as far as I can tell it is going to be pretty hard for me to destroy/scuff them.

At £149.99 these shoes are a tad pricey, but it is clear that a lot of thought has gone into the choice of materials and fit. Given a choice between spending a bit more money or spending less and foregoing the level of comfort these provide, I would happily pay more.

Lastly, and by no means least, they look pretty damn stylish. A couple of weeks ago I had to cycle to some exams and couldn’t fit another pair of shoes in my bag along with my massive textbook so I just wore my shiny M5 Donnas with a pair of jeans. Someone asked me where I got them from thinking they were just a pair of cool trainers!


Superbly comfortable shoes, worthy of their price tag with some great mountain bike specific features.


– Extremely comfortable
– Toe cap
– Look stylish


– No race version for women yet

Price: £149.99
Sizes: 36 – 43 (half sizes available)
More information: Fi’zi:k

What Fi’zi:k says about their M5 Donna Mountain bike shoes

High performance professional cycling shoes, handmade in Italy.

Materials: Microtex/Nylon Mesh/Anti-scratch Leather
Outsole: Nylon carbon-reinforced
Buckle: Aluminium loading lever
Straps: Sail cloth resitant
Insole: fi’zi:k superlight insole
Weight: 289g (size 38.5 without insole)


Newsletter Terms & Conditions

Please enter your email so we can keep you updated with news, features and the latest offers. If you are not interested you can unsubscribe at any time. We will never sell your data and you'll only get messages from us and our partners whose products and services we think you'll enjoy.

Read our full Privacy Policy as well as Terms & Conditions.